“Who is Bill Musgrave? The Raiders Hire a new Offensive Coordinator”
The Oakland Raiders yesterday added ex Jack Del Rio hire and Jacksonville Jaguar Offensive Coordinator Bill Musgrave as their new Offensive Coordinator. It was a surprise hire to many people.
Local fans may remember Bill Musgrave as a backup quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers and a few other teams. After his playing days, the Raiders hired him in 1997 as a quarterbacks coach. He had 4 really good years as a quarterback at the University of Oregon.
Musgrave is a journeyman coach who has never stayed at one place very long. He has been the OC of 5 teams in 17 years and in between that he’s been quarterbacks coach or an assistant.
As offensive coordinator with those 5 teams, he has had very mild success. His best year was in 2013 when the Vikings offense was 13th in total yards and 14th in scoring. As an OC, his offenses have never been in the top 12, and most have struggled. Before his job at Minnesota, he had never had a top 21 offense. He has had some good moments though and he’s a well respected and hard working guy. He’s also very well liked which definitely doesn’t hurt.
To his credit; even though it’s hard to give QB coaches all the credit; he did also have some nice years as quarterbacks coach. He was QB coach when Matt Ryan first started out and did well. Byron Leftwich was never great but his best year was when Musgrave was at Jacksonville.
Some like to give him a moderate amount of credit for Mark Sanchez having his best QB rating in his career in 2014 when Musgrave was QB coach of the Eagles. If you do that though, then you also have to give him the blame for Nick Foles who played half of the year before he got hurt. Foles threw for 27 touchdowns and had only 2 INTs in 2013 before Musgrave arrived. Last year in half a season with Musgrave as QB coach, Foles threw 13 TD’s with 10 interceptions and looked lost at times. Foles now is a question mark for the Eagles and they are debating whether to give him a big money long term contract.
As offensive coordinator it’s a much clearer picture with shaky results. He was no longer allowed to call the plays after only 4 games when he was the OC at Carolina in 2000. He was also let go by Jack Del Rio at Jacksonville after only 2 years of being an OC with near the worst offense in the NFL. In his defense he has never had great quarterbacks as a coordinator, but his style is pretty clear. He’s always had a conservative style of running the ball and running it often with a WR heavy passing game.
He did have some west coast influence with Mike Shanahan but he’s never truly instilled it into his offenses.
When he was first hired at Minnesota, the Minneapolis-St. Paul newspaper did two articles on him asking him about his philosophy. Most of it was just vague answers saying that he liked to mix up things and do a little bit of everything. He liked to talk about making communication between QB and play callers more simplified.
At Minnesota the offense was very straight forward. Run Adrian Peterson on first and second down, and then pass on third down if needed. The offense was a little more conservative than the approach at Kansas City with Alex Smith. With Adrian Peterson as your running back, there are worse options. Chris Ponder was the quarterback for most of the time, and he never grew into a good player.
Is he the right fit for Oakland?:
I think if the Raiders hired him as a quarterbacks coach, that this would have been a good hire. I think he’s solid and even with some fails he’s had some success too, and he’s a hard worker. The hopes are that he can help David Carr grow into a pocket quarterback that can command an offense. If he can do that alone, this will be a good hire. For those that cringed every time they saw Greg Olsen call a play, this is an upgrade by subtraction.
As an offensive coordinator this seems to obviously be a Jacksonville reunion with Mike Tice and Bill Musgrave working with head coach Jack Del Rio in the past. It’s hard to think Del Rio wasn’t the reason for the Musgrave hire. Musgrave struggled a lot though so it’s a surprise.
As an offensive coordinator, he was a nightmare in his first 4 jobs and his teams have mildly improved as he has gotten more experience. He’s never had a top 12 offense and to think that all of a sudden the Raiders are going to turn into juggernauts is hopeful at best. Let’s face it; it’s a league of talent though and if you have the talent, success will follow.
I think the love for some fans with Mark Trestman was strange. Trestman never called the plays or made the game plans when Jon Gruden was here; Gruden admitted he did. Trestman was supposed to fix the Bears and his lack of leadership and passive demeanor was ripped apart by both fans and the press alike in Chicago. Epic fail. Trestman wanted the Raider OC job; he said so in the press; but the Raiders obviously didn’t want him and it was a good move not to hire him.
This is another head scratcher in a long decade of head scratching hires by the Raiders. I like Mike Tice but this one is puzzling. Del Rio obviously feels comfortable with him and hopes that he can help David Carr grow.
I think Jack Del Rio is an upgrade at head coach. Even though they are a train wreck right now and 3-4 years away from being good, it’s hard to watch the Chicago Bears hire John Fox and DC Vic Fangio; two coaches with Super Bowl experience and who have had a ton of success; and then watch the Raiders hire Bill Musgrave; well, as they say, it is what it is. The hope is that somehow with the Raiders rebuilding their talent pool on offense, this will work out in Oakland and Carr and the offense will grow with Musgrave at the helm. I think he may do well for a while and be a stepping stone, but it’s hard to think of Bill Musgrave taking them to the highest level and raising Super Bowl trophies any time soon.