With the signing of ex Cincinnati safety Reggie Nelson, the Raiders filled another hole in their defense that needed to be addressed. In another cap friendly contract the Raiders get a solid run defender who is also fairly good against the pass. His high amount of interceptions is a good and bad thing; proves he can get interceptions but it also proves teams are not afraid to throw at him. He’s going to be 33 in September and that is probably the reason he didn’t get the money he wanted in free agency.
Someone asks me every week on Twitter why the Raiders don’t ever trade up. For the most part it’s because it’s not smart all the time.
Unless you need that one player to put you over the top, it’s not a good idea. Most teams that trade up get burned. Bill Belichick and the Patriots have been fleecing teams for years. I still remember the 2013 trade when the Vikings thought they were a WR away from being good. They traded a #2, #3, #4, & a #7 for New England’s #1 pick. At the 29th spot they chose Cordarrelle Patterson. While he’s been a fine return guy, he is now 5th on the WR depth chart and caught 2 passes all of last year. Four picks for a 5th string WR.
The Bills; overestimating their talent; sent their #9 overall pick in the first round along with a #1 and a #4 in 2015 to Cleveland to pick #4 overall in the 2014 draft to get talented WR Sammy Watkins. Watkins is good but I didn’t get that trade because the Bills had holes in their offensive line, QB and a few more on the defensive end.
Ron Wolf was never a huge fan of trading the first round pick either at Oakland or Green Bay, so I find it hard to think McKenzie will do it. Many fans like to talk trade scenarios but NFL teams are huge creatures of habit and unless the Raiders have fallen in love with a player, I don’t see them trading up.
What Are Their Needs Now?
The main needs are at middle linebacker, a defensive back, and another DL. They probably will also look into a RB and WR in the later rounds.
Ezekiel Elliott will probably go to Philadelphia or the Giants. A Running Back would be helpful to the Raiders as well but it’s not as big a need as people think. As I said before, I’m not a fan of Raiders OC Bill Musgrave. Not giving Marcel Reece and Jamize Olawale more carries is just ridiculous. The lack of imagination in using Roy Helu Jr. last year also hurt the Raiders. And to the writer that said Elliott was as good as Adrian Peterson in college? Elliot isn’t even close. Stop it.
Paralysis by Analysis:
I’ve been monitoring my draft picks for 16 years now. I want to be right so I take evaluating players seriously. Most just give brash comments and then move on to the next year but I want my followers to know they can trust my opinion. We all will be wrong at times but I want to have a history of quality picks and predictions mixed in with my Matt Leinart’s.
People wonder why so many teams make mistakes in the NFL draft. I think it’s because they over think it. Paralysis by Analysis; over analyzing. The more you look into something the more chance you will find fault in it. Now NFL teams are using an arrest formula to predict how many arrests a player will have. You can’t make this stuff up.
I think also NFL teams and experts are obsessed with athleticism over football talent. Darrius Heyward-Bey had no business being the Raiders top pick; in fact he was on my no draft list and to the dismay of Raider fans who applauded the pick, I destroyed the choice on draft day. DHB was picked purely because of his fast 40 time @ the NFL combines. He really wasn’t even that good at Maryland.
Look at the old videos on Youtube. I was watching the draft day video on Aaron Rodgers. Experts were justifying why he was falling in the draft. “He has bad hand placement; he has bad mechanics. Look how high he keeps his hands. He still has a chance to be a pretty good QB but Alex Smith by far is the best QB in the draft”.
From teams overreacting to Thurman Thomas’ knee, to Jerry Rice and Marcus Allen not being fast enough, the nitpicking gets to be a bit rough. I’m not saying the other stuff isn’t valuable but as John Madden said, watch the games, not drills with players in gym shorts. This is still football. Now let’s look at each position and the possible first round pick for the 2016 NFL draft.
This is going to be interesting. Many think that DL’s will fall in the draft because there are so many potential good ones. It wouldn’t be a surprise but my feeling is that only QB is more important than a DL so if there is one you like then you pick him. It will be fun to see.
I’m not a fan of this pick because in reality he had only 1 good year in college and his teammate; Shaq Lawson; was the one being double teamed most of the year which allowed him to be freed up. I like Lawson better. It wouldn’t be a tragedy to pick him but I think he’s overrated. I think Dodd is a borderline 1stround pick. Not a fan.
When I wrote on how Vernon Gholston would be a huge bust in the 2008 draft, Jets fans destroyed me. Some Raider fans wanted to draft him. In 3 years he ended up with ZERO sacks & never played again. I also was ripped apart on ESPN when someone shared the preview article I wrote with me saying how Jadeveon Clowney would also be a bust; 1500 thumbs down. This year I’m picking Nkemdiche as the poster child to avoid. His stats were like theirs.
In 3 years Nkemdiche only had 7 sacks. In his last 7 games last year he averaged 2 tackles a game. His best college year he had 3 sacks. For his career he averaged a little under 3 tackles a game. If that excites you then then that is cool but I pass on him big time. His football numbers don’t equal his athleticism.
His talent and work ethic are not questioned but his interviews are. He’s a good guy but some think he’s really not that passionate about football and with players retiring early, that is a big issue. This guy is a super hard worker. He’s big and has a great motor as they say. Nick Saban said he’s just learning how to pass rush and I think his push up the middle would be a great plus. He was double teamed a lot and was told to play a lot of 2 gap so in reality he was a key to clogging up the middle. As one scout said, he knows how to play and these guys are valuable.
I like Rankins as well. Like Robinson he’s raw as a pass rusher but scouts like him. He is physical and is a good tackler and he would help the Raiders.
Even with being double teamed often throughout the year, Lawson thrived. There were more than a few games where it was obvious he was the best player on the field. I think he’s a special talent that can’t be passed up. If Lawson and Rankins is there, I pick Lawson.
I think he’s the best cornerback in the draft. Great instinct, cover skills and recovery speed. He’s a film room junkie who works as hard as anyone in college football. Confident, physical and tough and he plays with a swagger. I love this guy. Teams just stopped throwing his way. He gave up 11 passes all last year and no touchdowns. NFL scouts hate that he’s only 5 10” but I don’t care. This guy is really good. If you pick him, now you have a great nickel back who has time to learn the position. TJ Carrie and Nelson and Nate Allen can play safety with Smith, Amerson & Alexander playing CB. A good mix of youth and experience.
Oh the fickle NFL draft. Remember when Hargreaves was in the top 5 of most everyone’s mock draft? Not anymore. In fact I just saw him falling as low as 16 now in an experts draft. Another great athlete but he gave up 16.5 yards per pass play and struggled in Florida’s two toughest games; Michigan and Alabama. Two months ago I said I liked Alexander over him and again got the idiot tag. I’ll stick by what I said.
There are slim pickings for MLB so it’s going to be tricky here. There really is only 1 first rounder with Kentrell Brothers being the next best MLB after Reggie Ragland but most think he’s a mid to late 2nd rounder.
Ragland is a classic Alabama linebacker who is a thumper. He is a good tackler and very physical. As I’ve said before, Alabama linebackers are a risk. Nick Saban plays almost all zone and LB’s at Bama don’t have to cover RB’s man to man. You literally don’t know if they can cover. The Raiders found that out with Rolando McClain. He wasn’t a good cover guy and the pick didn’t pan out. I’m not a fan of this pick because of the risk but again; but their are slim pickings at MLB this year.
Lee is the favorite for some but he is an OLB so I don’t get the love. It’s also a huge risk. Lee is a great athlete but he’s pretty lean for a LB position in the NFL and at times struggled against power blockers. He also has been playing LB for only 2 years; that’s in his life. He was a QB in high school and he played safety early on at OSU. A great athlete and again, that’s what the NFL likes but he has a lot to learn.
Wow; this guy has talent. I love his potential and I like him over Lee. He needs to be consistent and with the right coaching he can be something special. I would not be hurt by drafting Floyd and then getting a MLB in the later rounds. If he’ll play hard every play, he can be special. If the Raiders are looking at just talent, this guy is hard to pass up even though it doesn’t fix the MLB problem, but they could address it later.
Who will the Raiders pick?
If it was me I would take Lawson, Alexander and Floyd in that order. Floyd is moving up the charts I think and if he is a top 10 pick I would not be surprised. I would then pick a MLB in the 2nd or 3rd round.
No one really knows; not even the Raiders at this point; but I think the Raiders are going to go for the safest pick. The draft has very slim pickings at MLB and they really need one. As of now I see them drafting Reggie Ragland MLB out of Alabama. He can definitely start right away and if you draft an MLB in the lower rounds, they may not be ready to start. Ben Heeney is a nice backup but he’s not a full time starter IMHO.
Whoever they pick it will be another piece to help the Raiders attempt to be a playoff team. It’s hard to realize that there has never been a Tweet or a Facebook post that has ever talked about a Raiders playoff game. Facebook started in 2004 and Twitter in 2006. Hopefully for the Raiders that will end this year.